In 2000 the 1st Stars winner was

Joanna Winterbottom as Toyah

In 2001 the winner was

Antony Britton as George Formby

Other singers on the night included Lesley Bednall as Alison Moyet, Tony Jones as Neil Diamond, Jodie Dunnage as Lulu Star, Hayley Franks as Nicole Appleton from All Saints, Paul Smith as Robbie Williams, Kirstie Knight as Carol Decker from T’pau, Rebecca Kinley as Lene Marlin, Laura Thompson as Leanne Rhymes, Alex Toohey as Andrew Strong (Commitments) and Amy Mulhern as Dido.

2002 was

Sharon Ross as Cher

Other singers included Jodie Dunnage as Kylie Minogue, Mike Faragher as Joe Cocker, Karen Cahill as Natalie Umbruglia, Scott Bradshaw as Phil Collins, Tara/Jodie/Becky as Atomic Kitten, Paul Doherty as Will Young, Laura and Jenny as Barbara Dixon and Elaine Paige,  Martin & Andrew as The Everly Brothers, Tony Jones as Roy Orbison, Sinead McMullen as Madonna and Lesley Bell as Celene Dion.

2005 at the Villa saw

Stephanie Clift won as Eva Cassidy

Other singers included Mark O'Grady & Martyn Cull as The Bee Gees, Kirstie Knight as Elkie Brooks, Charlotte Corrigan as Leann Rimes, Richard Cull as Elton John, Rebecca Forrest as Whitney Houston, Jodie Dunnage as Christina Aguilera, Tori Radford as Avril Lavigne, Matthew Hankinson as Bobby Darin, Kathleen McGinley as Dolly Parton, Kelly Bennett as Sheryl Crow, Martin Linham as Raul Marlow and Carlos Mapano as Will Young.

2006 winner was 15 year old

Kiya Ennos as Olivia Newton John

Other singers included Les Harrison as Neil Diamond, Jodie Teare as Shakira, Lesley Bell as Patti Smith, Paul Dougherty as Shane from Westlife, Angela Kay as Judith Durrham from The Seekers, Scott Bradshaw as Keiser Chiefs, Liza Graham as Chritina Aguilera, Martyn Cull as Justin Hawkins from The  Darkness, Lauren Simpson as Pink, Emma Cash as Shirley Bassey, Kelly Bennett as Debbie Harry and Albert Shimmin as Tony Christie.

Also in 2006, the Manx Telecom audience text vote winner was

Joe Wylde as  James Blunt

the 2007 winner was

Mike Corkill as Pavarotti. 

Other singers included Sharon Ross as Tina Turner, Phil Carter as Ali Campbell, Tina Perryman as Annie Lennox, Mike Faragher as Neil Diamond, Jodie Teare as Faith Hill, Sarah Clarke as Chrystal Gayle, Trevor Nixon as John Lennon, Charlotte Corrigan as Shania Twain, Sarah Kinrade as Hannah Montana, Lauren Simpson as Katrina & The Waves, Fiona Feeney as Infernal, Jolene Clarke as Carol Decker from T’Pau, David Cain as Tony Burrell of Razorlight and Rebecca Forrest as Lulu.

The winner of 2008 was

Jodie Teare as Duffy

Other singers on the night included Jolene Clarke as Blondie, David Hugill as Neil Diamond, Rebecca Forrest as Amy Winehouse, Joe Wylde as James Morrison, Joy Catubig as Barbara Streisand, Danielle, Jade & Georgia as Atomic Kitten, Phil Carter as Robert Parmer, Mark Corkhill as Tony Hadley, Annaliisa Asveit as Tine Turner, Kathleen McGinley as KT Tunstall, Tom Dixon as Alex Band and Lesley Bell as Chrissie Hynde.